I am not a supporter of the proposed changes to the library fines. To begin with, I believe that 30 cents per day for overdue adult material is too high, and to match the juvenile rate to it is simply too expensive. I believe that 20 cents per day for overdue juvenile material is already too high, and I propose that it should be 10 cents instead. Here are my reasons for why I believe that the juvenile rate should not increase:
First, the proposed budget refers to the change as a "small increase;" however, I do not consider a 50% increase to be "small."
Second, I expect that a card holder that checks out juvenile material checks out many juvenile items at a time, even more items than an adult, so when a card holder misses renewing their books on time, it would result in fines that get very expensive very quickly.
Third, I know that there are many parents who hold their children responsible for their library books and paying for their own library fines. While 10 cents may seem like a "small increase" for people working with large budgets, for children and young adults, this increase in fines would take up a significant portion of their allowance. I would not like to see parents then stepping in to cover the fines, thereby reducing the responsibility and life-experience education of the child.
Fourth, I'm not sure why there needs to be such a steep fine for either juvenile or adults because I do not understand what expenses the library is incurring for someone keeping their book too long (for "short-term" overdue items). If it is to be a deterrent, then raise the fine as high as you will. But, if you want people, especially juveniles to access the material (which I personally believe is very important), then I would keep the fines as low as possible.
Fifth, does it really matter what the other jurisdictions are doing? We are already about the highest in the area, which seems unnecessary.
If this proposed change is implemented, I would ask that the library also send out a reminder email on the day that the library items are due, not just 3 days in advance. Perhaps the email system could be set up so that the individual card holder can set up their reminder emails on a schedule of their choosing.
On the other hand, I think that reducing DVD fines to 30 cents may be too dramatic of a cut, especially when the burden of covering this decrease then shifts to the children.
In this analysis, I am curious how much of the library system's checked-out material is for juveniles and how much is for adults. Then, going a step further, I'm curious what type of patron racks up the most in library fines.
Thank you for your time!